I adore that book. I think Fitzgerald has this amazingly crisp, simple, American writing style. His words are very New England - he doesn't use any more than what's necessary in his prose, but what he does use is made to work perfectly. In my opinion, he's Hemingway but bearable.
(Yeah. I just said it. I JUST SAID IT. I don't enjoy Hemingway. Fine. Feast on my flesh.)
Whenever any of my fellow English majors have started in on the age-old "There's no great American novel!" lament, I won't have any of it. The great American novel is The Great Gatsby (and no, not just because it has "great" in the title). The book is about the emergence of the United States as a corrupt, immigrant-supported superpower billed as the Place Where Dreams Come True (but really winds up being The Place Where You Get Super Rich and Then Shot In Your Pool).
And what's 10,000 more awesome is that it says all that in what seems to be a story about this guy who never got over this girl who dumped him for some other guy and then he got sad.
The thesis of The Great Gatsby is that believing in the American Dream (I will work hard, I will have all these things, and all these things will make me happy) is as dumb as staying in love with a girl who leaves you for a white supremacist with a weird mustache.
I'm excited for this movie because I wasn't a huge fan of the 1974 Robert Redford movie...actually, Redford (and the DA from Law & Order playing Nick Carraway) was really all I liked about it. (Yes. I have a Redford fetish, and don't you dare judge me because there was a time when his face didn't look like the moon's surface). You could tell through the whole thing that Mia Farrow was pregnant, and I just thought that such a muted book about such powerful subject matter worked poorly as such a muted movie.
That's the thing about movies; they have to do what the books can't. They have to find the limitation of the manuscript and exploit it.
This is a pretty beautiful trailer, so I have high hopes for Luhrmann's interpretation. His whimsical style and fondness for decadent costumes and cinematography stand a good chance at telling this story. Because it is a decadent story, despite the simple language.
The limitations of the book are that we can't see anything. We can't see the diamonds and the clothes and the glitz and everything that makes Gatsby's world so tangibly rich and so spiritually barren.
I really hope this isn't another instance of Great Trailer Horrible Movie-itis. I've had enough of that. But I'm optimistic. Watching the scene with all the shirts makes me think it'll be good. Also, Carey Mulligan is the right age for Daisy. And since when has Leonardo not made anything better?
One issue: this movie comes out, like, a matter of hours before I'm getting married. Which will IN NO WAY prohibit me from seeing it. It's just going to make Christmas 2012 a lot more complicated, and I thought that couldn't happen.





